INTRODUCTION
Interactions between clinicians and patients are increasingly happening across diverse backgrounds, requiring trust to be built during sensitive times. The pervasive nature of implicit or unconscious biases can hinder this process. To support clinicians in navigating these biases and fostering provider resilience while delivering high-quality, patient-centered care, practical tools are essential. While guidance exists, readily available tools for clinicians are not widely known. This article introduces the “5Rs of Cultural Humility (5Rs)” as a valuable Client Care Tool List accessible to all clinicians, leaders, and administrators. This tool promotes awareness of universal implicit biases and offers a framework to address them through cultural humility, mindfulness, and compassion. It encourages clinicians to enhance their self-awareness regarding decision-making and interactions. Each “R” focuses on bias reduction and includes a self-reflection question. The 5Rs are: Reflection, Respect, Regard, Relevance, and Resiliency. This framework provides clinicians with a structured approach to cultivate more mindful interactions and enrich patient-provider relationships.
IMPLICIT BIASES AND CULTURAL HUMILITY: ESSENTIAL CLIENT CARE TOOLS
Terms such as female/male, white/black, citizen/immigrant, cis/trans, and straight/gay are powerful identifiers that can subtly and overtly influence human interactions. Implicit biases are unconscious attitudes that impact our understanding of others, leading to differential treatment. [1, 2] Clinicians are not exempt from these biases. [3–5] The manifestation of implicit biases can negatively affect the patient-provider relationship, potentially harming both patients and providers. [6] Regular pauses for reflection on care within this relationship are crucial in clinical practice. [7]
To address these challenges, the Society of Hospital Medicine’s Practice Management Committee developed the “5Rs of Cultural Humility” as a client care tool list. [8] This concise framework assists clinicians in confronting implicit biases and choosing more mindful responses. Originally designed for hospitalists, its universal applicability makes it a valuable tool for all healthcare professionals. Focusing on cultural humility empowers individuals to navigate cultural nuances effectively and challenge stereotypes.
The 5Rs client care tool list comprises Reflection, Respect, Regard, Relevance, and Resiliency. This tool incorporates proven strategies for mitigating implicit biases in healthcare, including perspective-taking, emotional regulation, and partnership building. [1, 9] Each “R” has a specific aim to reduce biases and provides self-coaching through a reflective question. This article will explore implicit biases and cultural humility, detail the application of the 5Rs tool, and elaborate on each of its core tenets.
UNDERSTANDING IMPLICIT BIASES IN HEALTHCARE: A CRITICAL CLIENT CARE NEED
Acknowledging and understanding the influence of one’s own implicit biases is a complex but vital aspect of effective client care. [4] Online assessments are available to help individuals uncover their biases. [10] It’s crucial to recognize that clinicians’ implicit biases can impact treatment decisions. [4] Therefore, interventions are necessary to minimize potential discrimination.
A Cochrane review analyzing cultural competency training showed some success in reducing biases, which can be seen as a foundational client care tool. [11] However, despite the absence of negative studies, the evidence for cultural competency training alone remains inconclusive. [11]
Cultural humility represents the next evolution in cultural understanding and is a more impactful client care tool than just competency. [12] Unlike cultural competency, cultural humility does not necessitate expertise in any specific social group, institution, or belief system. Instead, cultural humility is a lifelong commitment to self-reflection and self-critique, aimed at addressing power imbalances and advocating for others. [13] Practicing cultural humility effectively mitigates implicit bias, enhances empathy, and empowers providers to acknowledge and respect patient individuality. [13] The universal principles of cultural humility emphasize the provider’s need to connect with patients on a human level, rather than attempting to be an expert on their race, culture, or ethnicity. This connection is a cornerstone of patient-centered client care.
APPLYING THE 5RS CLIENT CARE TOOL LIST IN PRACTICE
The primary goal of the 5Rs of Cultural Humility client care tool list is to increase awareness in clinical encounters. This enhanced awareness is intended to improve healthcare by reducing disparities, strengthening the patient-clinician relationship, emphasizing our shared humanity, and fostering provider resilience. The tool’s aims and questions incorporate key skills for reducing implicit biases in healthcare, such as perspective-taking, emotional regulation, and partnership-building. [1, 9]
The reflective questions within the 5Rs framework serve as a coaching mechanism, making this client care tool list versatile in its application. It can be used for self-coaching, small group discussions, workshops, and peer-to-peer coaching or counseling. The time dedicated to reflection can vary depending on the context. A clinician might take a few moments for self-reflection during inpatient rounds or between clinic appointments. In contrast, using the tool to stimulate deeper reflection, discussion, and coaching in peer counseling, group settings, or workshops can range from a few minutes to an hour or more. This flexibility enhances its practical value as a client care tool.
THE 5RS OF CULTURAL HUMILITY: A DETAILED CLIENT CARE TOOL LIST
Reflection: Learning from Every Patient Encounter
Aim: Clinicians will approach each patient encounter with humility, recognizing that there is always something to learn from every individual.
Self-Reflection Question: What did I learn from each person in that encounter?
Clinicians possess expertise in their specific fields. However, approaching each encounter with humility acknowledges that there is always more to learn beyond one’s area of specialization. Reflection in medicine requires clinicians to pause and consider what can be learned from each situation and to find meaning in these encounters. The guiding question for this “R” encourages clinicians to identify learning opportunities that extend beyond their current understanding.
Reflection is integral to practicing humility. While humility can be misconstrued as self-doubt, evidence suggests it is perceived as a strength in exemplary clinical professionals. [14] Reflection also enables clinicians to make sense of challenging patient situations in relation to their own experiences. [15] A reflective clinician can navigate personal emotional responses to patient suffering and demanding care situations with engaged concern, maintaining a sense of self. [15] Compassion is central to healing, emphasizing the shared human experience in all circumstances. Recognizing individuality within this interconnectedness allows practitioners of the 5Rs of Cultural Humility to learn from interactions. Intentional self-reflection becomes a strength, counteracting clinician disengagement. [16] Cultivating clinician reflection contributes to well-being and strengthens the dedication to providing quality client care.
Respect: Preserving Dignity in Every Interaction
Aim: Clinicians will treat every person with the utmost respect, striving to preserve dignity at all times.
Self-Reflection Question: Did I treat everyone involved in that encounter respectfully?
Respect involves honoring individuals by showing care, concern, and consideration for their needs and feelings. Respect extends to everyone involved in a patient encounter, including other care providers, family members, and the clinician themselves. [17] This “R” is designed to support clinicians during challenging circumstances. The associated question prompts clinicians to assess their actions and ensure they align with the value of respect.
Patients’ health knowledge and decisions are personal, diverse, and influenced by their environment, cultural beliefs, and socioeconomic status. [18] Clinicians have a moral obligation to treat patients with respect by incorporating patient choices, preferences, and boundaries with evidence-based care. [19] Respect empowers patients to actively participate in decisions about their care. It requires clinicians to understand patient reasoning, seek clarification, and offer guidance, even when patient expectations or decisions differ from their own values or medical advice. Pausing to consider the “R” of respect promotes a dignified environment and values each person as an individual human being. [19]
Regard: Valuing Individuality and Belief Systems
Aim: Clinicians will hold every person in the highest regard, being aware of and preventing unconscious biases from interfering in any interactions.
Self-Reflection Question: Did unconscious biases drive this interaction?
Clinicians often care for patients from diverse backgrounds during vulnerable times. Whether in a hospital or clinic, clinicians are often unfamiliar to patients and must quickly build trust and rapport. Holding a patient in high regard facilitates this connection. The aim of regard is to value each patient for their individuality and belief system. The reflective question for this “R” encourages clinicians to examine their own biases, both implicit and explicit.
Having regard for patients requires acknowledging that everyone possesses implicit biases that unconsciously affect understanding, actions, and decisions. [2] Clinicians hold unconscious beliefs about various social and identity groups [3–5], which can create risks of discrimination in healthcare decisions. [20] Furthermore, clinician biases can influence how patients perceive verbal communication, empathy, and non-verbal body language. [21–23]
Integrating regard into the 5Rs framework raises awareness of potential biases, enabling clinicians to recognize, neutralize, and modify thoughts before they manifest as behaviors. Patients who sense they are valued and understood are more likely to develop trusting relationships with their clinicians. [24] This trust fosters a more therapeutic patient-provider relationship, a critical component of client care.
Relevance: Integrating Cultural Humility into Client Care Values
Aim: Clinicians will recognize cultural humility as relevant and apply this practice to every encounter.
Self-Reflection Question: How was cultural humility relevant in this encounter?
The relevance of cultural humility is intrinsically linked to the clinician’s pursuit of quality and the promotion of patient-centered care (PCC). The reflective question for this “R” prompts consideration of cultural humility’s importance alongside other values in the healthcare system.
The Institute of Medicine advocates for timely, safe, evidence-based medicine within a PCC model that is judicious and impartial. [25] Furthermore, PCC is an integral part of value-based purchasing, a Centers for Medicare and Medicaid incentive program that rewards hospitals based on care quality rather than quantity. It incorporates quality measures, patient outcomes, and the patient experience. [26]
Transforming healthcare to improve outcomes and reduce disparities requires a deeper understanding of the bio-psycho-social aspects of all patients. Relevance, within the 5Rs of Cultural Humility, guides clinicians in advocating for their patients. The practice of cultural humility recognizes patients’ capacity to discuss, engage in, collaborate on, and choose their care plans. Embracing the relevance of cultural humility balances the power dynamic in the patient-clinician relationship by acknowledging the equal value of both partners.
Resiliency: Enhancing Clinician Well-being and Compassion
Aim: Clinicians will embody the practice of cultural humility to enhance personal resilience and global compassion.
Self-Reflection Question: How was my personal resiliency affected by this interaction?
Cultural humility enables clinicians to recognize their expertise in their fields while acknowledging patients as experts in their own lives. The aim and question for resiliency highlight the shared humanity of clinicians, patients, and everyone involved. The associated question for this “R” encourages clinicians to prioritize self-care as part of client care.
In an era of escalating clinician burnout, interventions and tools to enhance resilience are critical. [27] Among the components of burnout, physicians are particularly vulnerable to depersonalization and emotional exhaustion during difficult encounters. [28] Cultural humility can counteract burnout risk during these challenging interactions. This “R” emphasizes the importance of extending compassion to oneself and others during times of suffering. Reflecting on one’s personal state influences subsequent communication and interactions, directly impacting client care. Promoting practices that improve communication reduces burnout risk while strengthening patient connections. [29] Resiliency is therefore a vital component of a comprehensive client care tool list.
FUTURE RESEARCH DIRECTIONS FOR THE 5RS CLIENT CARE TOOL LIST
The mutual benefits for clinicians and patients from implementing the 5Rs of Cultural Humility client care tool list are currently conceptual. However, real-time feedback during a Society of Hospital Medicine conference presentation in 2018 indicated a strong desire for more time, attention, and training on implementing the 5Rs in practice. Further empirical research is therefore essential. [30] Testing the 5Rs will contribute to understanding how to mitigate implicit bias in a field lacking established methodologies. [30] Future research could include quantitative patient satisfaction scoring and qualitative methods to assess the tool’s intended outcomes of improving patient care and clinician resilience. These approaches will provide valuable feedback for clinicians adopting the 5Rs in their professional practice.
CONCLUSION: THE 5RS AS AN ESSENTIAL CLIENT CARE TOOL LIST
Clinicians are susceptible to implicit biases, which can harm patient-provider relationships and negatively impact both patients and providers. The practice of cultural humility is a powerful approach to mitigate implicit bias, enhance empathy, and help clinicians acknowledge and respect patient individuality. The 5Rs of Cultural Humility client care tool list provides clinicians with a concise framework to begin addressing implicit biases and choosing more mindful and compassionate responses. This tool list represents a significant step forward in improving client care in diverse healthcare settings.
Compliance with Ethical Standards
Conflict of Interest
The authors declare no conflict of interest.
Footnotes
Publisher’s Note
Springer Nature remains neutral concerning jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
